I remember
when I was a little boy and my mother would go through my pockets as she did
laundry and she’d find all sorts of things, rocks, paperclips, toys, bottle
caps, bits of string and lots of dirt. I don’t recall why I had collected those
items and put them in my pockets, but I did. I’m sure I had some purpose for
them more than being an annoyance to my mother.
I started
this morning writing about the differences between irony and coincidence. In my
brief research into the subject I realized it is a swelled and complex issue
with far too much sub-text to delve into so early in the day. I mean there’s a
lot going into the very definition of irony that I can’t be sure I even know
what it means anymore. The most reasonable definition I found of irony is “the
literal meaning is opposite to the intended”; so, for example, “clear as mud”,
or “hard as a cloud”.
We know mud
is thick and difficult to see through and that clouds are vapor and likely
soft. So the literal meaning is different than the intended meaning. This of
course has to assume the listener or reader is aware that mud is difficult to
see through and what clouds are made of for the irony to be effective.
Otherwise the irony is lost on them.
But it
still doesn’t change the confusion between coincidence and irony that I hear
all too often. Let’s say you’re talking about Jack Nicholson to a friend in a
passing conversation and later, when you get home, you turn the TV on and
there’s a Jack Nicholson movie playing. That’s not ironic. It’s a coincidence.
However, if you were talking to Jack Nicholson about Jack Nicholson and he said
he’d never act in another movie and he goes home, turns on his TV and there’s a
movie on about you, then that would be ironic.
A friend of
mine recently wrote a wonderful piece about real Chicago Firemen and how she
just couldn’t stomach the show, “Chicago Fire”, because she’d seen the real
thing. I found out yesterday that the building next to my offices, a former
Police station, will be used in the coming weeks for some location shooting for
the very same television show, “Chicago Fire”. This is a coincidence. It only
has significance because my friend wrote about it so recently and it was fresh
on my mind. It may seem ironic, but it’s not.
This “Chicago
Fire” coincidence is what brought this whole article into my mind
actually. I’m not sure what else I had
to say about it. It was just rattling around in the old brain box and needed to
be hosed off and put on a shelf. Just one of the things I had in my pockets I
guess.
Sorry, Mike, but I beg to differ with you about your second Jack example--I don't think that would be irony either (if I read your set-up correctly.) Jack tells me he's not going to act in any more movie, goes home, and sees a movie about me? I would think it is closer to a coincidence than irony, but I have not actually looked at any definitions.
ReplyDeleteBut what are the odds that you'd be in a movie? It's situational irony. But again, Irony is difficult to define as there are many forms: verbal Irony, Dramatic Irony, and Situational Irony. But I appreciate your comment and hope you continue reading, Anonymous. :)
ReplyDelete